This story is told over a 10 day span and from lots of viewpoints. The majority are from the main characters of Emmett, Billy, Wooly and Duchess but then you get several secondary character viewpoints thrown in as well throughout the book. Little of the story actually has to do with the Lincoln Highway. The Greek myth about Ulysses factors into the story as well and there is lots of conversations and telling about that legend throughout as well as other heroes that Billy refers to from his book that he reads and there is Christian/religious thoughts thrown in throughout as well. I liked this story in some parts but didn't love it as a whole. It's hard to describe why. I liked the idea of the story and the gist of it. But certain parts I really didn't like at all including the ending. I loved certain characters, was indifferent to others, wondered why some were even in there, and totally disliked others. I thought parts of the telling were way too wordy with too many bunny trails and it could have been shortened up a bit though other reviews loved the telling of it. I couldn't help but sigh when there was two pages spent on describing in detail a clown's act when he was a minute mention in one chapter. I felt the story started to get somewhat muddled with all the antics and chaos that Duchess brought. It kind of got old after awhile for me. The author chose to use no quotation marks in the conversations instead using a dash whenever someone spoke or started dialogue. It took a long time for me to fall into that style and so the first part of the book was choppy for me but once I got used to it it flowed more smoothly. One part where the author really lost me was when he chose a couple of vulgar swear words and paired it with Jesus' name. That soooo offends me and I don't understand why an author has to stoop to that and bring an offense like that to a section of his readership. I pressed on in the hope it wasn't used again or I would put the book down and fortunately it wasn't. The rating I would have given dropped because of this. I loved Gentleman in Moscow and had high hopes for this one but it was just alright for me.
I gave it a 7/10
Thanks for your review. I had wondered about this book, but had not put it on my "to read" list. Sounds like there are some books I would rather read. Thanks again and have a good week.
ReplyDeleteI recently read another review of this book from a long-time blog friend who reached the same conclusions. That's too bad. I loved Gentleman in Moscow so much, I would have hoped for more than this. I read the first few pages that Amazon made available. While parts of the premise were intriguing, it just didn't grab me. So I doubt I'll pick it up.
ReplyDeleteI agree about the swear words and using Jesus' name that way.
Hm....I have yet to read A Gentleman in Moscow (both daughters LOVED it and my youngest says it's in the basement..when she has a chance she will dig it out for me). I've seen this on our library shelves in town but never felt drawn to it. Will probably pass. I agree about vulgur language...this is NO need for it and GOOD...as in EXCELLENT literary authors do NOT need those words. They know how to get the point across with out them. Thanks for the review. (oh and I agree with what you said about my latest review...definitely avoiding that Christian author in the future..no wonder I've not seen many of our small groups at church use her or her husband's studies!!!)
ReplyDeleteSame as above. Gentleman in Moscow stands alone among Towles' other works. I had gotten the audiobook version of Rules of Civility and couldn't like it near as much as Gentleman in Moscow.
ReplyDeleteAppreciate your review, even if you couldn't pinpoint all the ways the story derailed for you.